Walking Tree wrote:
that answers the question all right.
Is that the post about swampland not having 'true' breakfast settings etc ?
Um, sure. I should qualify that a bit. See, here's how it happened and what I was thinking.
For some reason, my client at some point wasn't showing me Armagoshdarnish, which I had really started to enjoy playing. It would always poll as unavailable. The problem got fixed, but only after I became hooked on Breakfast Burrito, which later renamed to Breakfast of Champions (and is allegedly the original name of that server). But BoC wasn't reliable, it would frequently go down for hours, sometimes days at a time, and with ish not showing properly on my server browser there wasn't any place left that I really enjoyed playing.
So I made a clone. Called it Breakfast of Demons, later renamed to Breakfast in Hell. Started with eggcozy's settings. I ran a few variations, you know, a team server, and the cool mass destruction server (in-cam only). It was never intended to replace BoC, only to serve as a backup on the occasions that BoC was unavailable. Decompyler ran a clone too, because my internet connection is crap and people didn't like the lag on my server. Then I stumbled across swampland, noticed that I really liked the settings and asked Swampy where he got them. Turned out he was cloning BoC too.
So at this point I started wondering how eggcozy would feel if we all ran our clones and started doing things to differentiate them from one another. Decompyler already had and people were already saying "It's not Breakfast" over there. So I started wondering where the line was to be drawn to define Breakfast and Not Breakfast. Then Decompyler disappeared and his server with him, leaving it just me, Swampy, and eggcozy. Egg's server was down for awhile too, so just Swampy's and mine were the ones left, and are still the ones left.
I made the website right before Decompyler disappeared, and he has/had an account there. As did eggcozy. I used some code Decompyler sent me to parse stat files and started running the stat page for all Breakfast servers, and there was some unity. Not a lot, we're all fiercely independent types, so it's more of a loose affiliation.
And I started wondering who owned the name Breakfast. The players had adopted it for themselves as something of a personal identity thing (the way women with large boobs depend on their boobs as part of their self identity). It had been a cool name that eggcozy dreamed up, and an armagetron phenomena that originated with him, so he was kinda authoritative on the matter. But being independent and respecting others' independence, he kept quiet and just played the game. (I don't think I ever heard him say a bad thing about anybody's server until right before he took off, when he let it all out) So what happens if eggcozy tries to assert ownership of it? You know, completely? The way Thompson did with mp3, first let everyone have it and do what they want, then assert ownership and take it. On the one hand, it was his and I wanted to make sure I respected that at all times, but on the other hand the community adopted it. And swampy and I had been tossing around ideas to try to milk some money out of the players (in exchange for real value, I might add, we're not crooks). If anything happened there, you know, if it turned into real money, eggcozy could make some serious trouble if he wanted. On the other hand, he's a cool guy, and I'd never try to screw him out of anything. I'm not that kind of guy either, so I didn't think any trouble would happen. But he never expressed interest in it anyway, and I had a feeling that he wouldn't get involved in a commercial pursuit, and I did ask him directly but his answer was evasive. Leaving me wondering where he sat.
In the end, eggcozy asserted the authority to define what Breakfast was, and some of the regular players (including a couple of admins) disagreed with his definition. So at this point, I figure there's no reason to fight over a name, and even though he's gone, there's still the whole issue of who owns it. We can all still assert ownership of it if we want, but I'm not really interested in doing that. I'd just as soon come up with an even cooler name and go with it and we can put Breakfast of Champions on the pile with the original goshdarn and whatever other legendary servers there have been, and I think we should respect eggcozy's contribution to the game and make a happy memory out of what could turn into an ugly memory. And we can't forget that both Swampland and the Crack Pipe have very strong roots in eggcozy's server, regardless of what disagreements might exist. So it boils down to a simple question of growth. Do we want to grow as a group, or degenerate and factionalize over a silly name? I see growth in the name change, and new possibilities opening up when I stand on my own feet and declare my server is mine and have no current loyalty to conforming to any definition of good gameplay other than what my players and myself agree is what makes it fun for all of us to play together.
So that's how we wind up with Breakfast in Hell changing its name.
So, to replace the part of Breakfast that identifies a genre, I'm thinking the new name shouldn't identify a genre, instead it should identify a common set of values that server admins respect that creates the atmosphere that exists on our servers that makes people want to play there and have fun doing it. In that vein, the new name won't reflect server settings at all, it'll reflect the attitudes of the players and the admin(s), so it doesn't even have to be part of the server name anymore. Granted, a cool name can show lots of cool permutations of server names that can be very entertaining, but I also remember how confusing it was when people knew their favorite server only by the name "Breakfast" and there were several different versions using that name. So instead I'm thinking of just having a line in the MOTD, or having something between rounds to remind players that this server is affiliated with that server over there, and the website will reflect whose servers are whose and so forth. And the name becomes less important, merely a convenience to distinguish preferred servers, which is how I'd always used the name Breakfast anyway.