unfortunately named persons and teams

A place for threads related to tournaments and the like, and things related too.

Moderator: Light

Locked
User avatar
Monkey
Shutout Match Winner
Posts: 825
Joined: Thu May 22, 2008 12:36 am
Location: England, UK

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Monkey »

Word wrote:The Americans to their credit never had death camps for organized annihilation of a demographic they felt was inferior to them
Instead, they had slavery of a demographic they felt was inferior to them.
Word wrote:...and they didn't invade other countries without warning because they were arrogant enough to attempt World domination.
Firstly, the USA itself exists due to "invasion without warning" by the British...and yes, the British were attempting World domination, hence the term "British Empire". Maybe we should exclude names such as "Team UK" too...
Secondly, it depends on your definition of World domination. The USA has been the global superpower for quite some time now. It didn't get there by playing nicely with other countries, that's for sure.

@Vogue
I don't believe in God or the Devil either but there are many people that do and I know plenty who would be highly offended by a nickname relating to the Devil.
Playing since December 2006
Amaso.
On Lightcycle Grid
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:44 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Amaso. »

Monkey wrote:
@Vogue
I don't believe in God or the Devil either but there are many people that do and I know plenty who would be highly offended by a nickname relating to the Devil.
THANK YOU. So Lucifer name change pls k ty
User avatar
Phytotron
Formerly Oscilloscope
Posts: 5042
Joined: Thu Jun 09, 2005 10:06 pm
Location: A site or situation, especially considered in regard to its surroundings.
Contact:

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Phytotron »

Is this kid for real? The degree of ignorance, myopia, irrationality, incoherence, lack of nuance combined with idiotic literalism, nonsensical relativism, absence of empathy, and just plain stupidity in Durf's posts, here and elsewhere, is literally jaw-dropping.
jwdrp.gif
jwdrp.gif (1.87 MiB) Viewed 5084 times
Seriously, is he for real? I can't take it.
Durf
Match Winner
Posts: 426
Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2012 10:35 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Durf »

@Phytotron, I shouldn't have to tell you the same thing I'm going to tell to dinobro. Stop your hate filled propaganda. In short I am for real. No amount of trolling whatsoever. The proper course of action would be to quote me and show everyone how exactly I am showing:
ignorance, myopia, irrationality, incoherence, absence of empathy, and just plain stupidity
..Making blatant insults and claims on what I've posted (as if they were fact) without any proof or empirical evidence is nothing more than harassment. You are entitled to your opinion, but you could simply say you disagree if you have nothing else of value to say. Publicly trying to tarnish my name with your empty accusations will only make you seem like more of an ass.
I should be able to post my opinion here without having to be directly insulted by disrespectful ignoramuses (that is my opinion of those who cannot have a civil discussion).


@Amaso.: You raise a VERY valid point (assisted by Monkey). If a team name is put up to this much scrutiny, and a forum name "Hitler" was indeed renamed forcibly, then it stands to reason that Lucifer should be forced to rename as well. It can be VERY offensive to many religious people. Think of how many people won't even try to play a corrupted and demonic game? (Moderator associates with the devil; some Christians are told to avoid bad associations by their God.)
I'd like to see what Lucifer has to say about this, as any defense he has for his name is defending a team name like "N4zi" to be able to exist (just as his name exists without problem).
To be clear, I support the freedom to represent yourself how you choose.


@Monkey, Thank you. For everything you posted. Saved me replying to Word (and Vogue). WD.


@Tank Program: I shouldn't have to ask more than 3 times for the harassment against me to stop, and STILL have my requests for a more peaceful thread be ignored. Funny thing is, I never got any warning for my alleged "sexism" (which I'm still trying to discuss with Z-Man; it was unjust)...so how is it fair that dinobro (and Phytotron) are allowed to continue? I suggest you take action against someone who can't listen to a person asking to stop harassment. Clearly a reasoned approach has already failed.


@Lucifer & .Lightning: If you don't want any part in it, don't take part in it.
I believe that prejudice and racism is a real issue, just like sexism is. And just like sexism, it is not only one-way. By definition (the good thing about concise wording), it is capable of existing both ways (probably not in equal amounts). Yes, everyone knows that some Nazis were very racist, and during war times many crimes were committed - that doesn't mean that you are unable to be racist against them, nor does it mean that they would deserve it.
Point is, this is about the difference between "prejudice and negative discrimination against tronners using the name 'N4zi'" and "banning offensive material".
If you have a valid point to offer, then post. If all you're going to do is complain, why are you here? There is a real issue that should be discussed in order to prevent unfair treatment (of anyone). Like I said though, if you don't want any part in it, then don't participate.
(Also @Lucifer, refer to my reponse "@Amaso.". I'd like to see what you have to say regarding what Amaso. and Monkey posted.)


@Vogue, you're not helping anyone. Not your enemies, not your friends.
Also, you are the one comparing a political view to mass murderers...not all Nazis were (or are) criminals.
Your prejudice against them needs to stop. Bringing religion into politics won't help either.. If the goal is to make the discussion more convoluted, then you're on the right track.


@Johnathan:
Yes, Nazism "technically" "hates" "Jews" (at least before the war it did). But that doesn't mean that Nazis or Nazism = genocide. Nor does it mean that anyone who is Nazi performs such acts (not all Nazis are criminals, not all Nazis kill). What you are feeling is prejudice. Negative emotions based on a preconception your formed from history (rather, the parts that were taught to you) and what you see in TV and movies. The "problem" isn't that they act out the associations (whether or not it's just a joke)...the "problem, is that YOU don't like Nazis based on what YOU think they are. YOU want to disallow a tronner to name THEIR OWN TEAM a name they want because YOU have bad feelings over a word...a single word. I'm not defending Nazism nor am I condoning it. I'm clearing up the difference between complete bias and what is actually harmful to others.
As I said in another thread, if the word gets you so worked up, why aren't you complaining about TV or movies, History books, and this thread itself? This thread alone mentions the word "Nazi" more times that the team name "N4zi" would appear on people's screens over the course of the ladle. Consider why you're allowing it to occur here, but not there. (clue: it's context. You're purposely interpreting a negative context for the team name)

Furthermore, I don't pretend I live in a vacuum where nothing means anything, rather I'm aware that any one thing can have multiple meanings. Far from naivety, it's the realization that one doesn't have to make a complete ass of himself by making assumptions on what means what. Just because I play "Devil's advocate" from time to time, it shouldn't mean I myself should be condemned for the position I'm discussing.

When you say "going full Nazi?", you have no proof that they are Nazi or even trying to associate themselves as REAL Nazis. It could be merely for shock value. Why is that reason to ban it? Really, all desires to ban it are based on the preconceptions you carry around with you.


@Gonzap, I'm glad you see who is just here to hate. Even after I've been asking for this harassment to stop.
Either the moderators will show some integrity, or favoritism. The harassment is just attempts to silence me when they have no reasoning or logic to do the work for them...sad really that they resort to hate.

Though, I find it sad that you couldn't enjoy an online game with actual Nazis. THAT being said, using a team name "N4zi" isn't necessarily a declaration that the tronners who are in the team are Nazis IRL. They are tronners. Just like you. Whether it is because they thought they are being cool or not, shouldn't matter. You should be able to play a game without going all "Nazi" on them for being "N4zi".
My overall point is, relax it's just a game. (playing with Nazis doesn't mean you support or condone their customs; and playing with "N4zi"s doesn't have to mean you are playing with Nazis).


@takburger, you realize you're talking about tronners right? Not actual Nazis?
It's just a team name...People seem to be forgetting that. And even if they were REAL Nazis...what are they doing to this community? Participating in ladle? OH NOES! Seriously though...what crime is being committed?
You are getting so caught up in trying to protect what is right that you lost sight of what's actually happening here. Don't get so worked up over the word "Nazi", this is tron, we're dealing with a team name (as others point out about forum names, there is plenty to get offended over, but why would you when you can have the understanding that you're just playing a game together.)
Playing with Nazis (or fake "N4zi"s / trolls trolling) does NOT mean you support or condone Nazism IRL. You are the only one making that relation, and that is the cause of you feeling offended by the name.


@dinobro: I thought I asked you to stop the hate. Stop the hate-filled propaganda you post in an attempt to besmirch me.
Frankly "everyone" isn't telling me that I'm "wrong" (per se). We are discussing in detail our own view points on the matter (thread title). And even if it was "everyone" that had an opposing view point than me, no one seems to be able to offer any real case against the name being allowed (one that isn't based on prejudice). It's certainly not being stubborn as I would have to lie...genuinely lie, to be able to agree with you. If you want me to agree with you, convince me. Teach me.
I never claimed to be smarter than anyone here, and I'm certainly not trying to prove that. My position on this should be clear: I'm supporting everyone's individual freedom to represent themselves how they want. (which means if people had a problem with "Dino", I would be defending your freedom to name yourself what you want) I'm not condoning hate or offensive material, I'm only questioning what is actually offensive.
Like I've said in my previous posts, I'm sorry that I cannot be concise enough for you. Though I don't expect you to see anything other than "bullshit posts"...I understand that sometimes things I say would just go over your head. The least you could do is quote me where I don't make sense. And show everyone.
Spreading lies won't help you succeed in besmirching me though.
User avatar
compguygene
Adjust Outside Corner Grinder
Posts: 2346
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 12:09 pm
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Contact:

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by compguygene »

This topic is complete balderdash. The definition of the word balderdash: senseless, stupid, or exaggerated talk or writing; nonsense.

I am going to summarize what seems to be the only worthy thought here. A team named N4zi with team members named after historical Nazi party members including Hitler is just not acceptable to us in this game as a Ladle team, period. No new rule needed. In several European countries in which this game is played, such would be illegal. Most any other name, within the limits of "family friendly" is pretty much fair game. Lucifer is fine. I say that as a well known Christian, by the way.
No, the only thing nearly as ridiculous as this team name is the balderdash of debate about it. None is needed. What is there to debate? Even if you are going to forgo the offensive nature of the name, it's illegal in some relevant countries!
Armagetron: It's a video game that people should just play and enjoy :)
https://bit.ly/2KBGYjvCheck out the simple site about TheServerPharm
Durf
Match Winner
Posts: 426
Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2012 10:35 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Durf »

compguygene wrote:This topic is complete balderdash. The definition of the word balderdash: senseless, stupid, or exaggerated talk or writing; nonsense.

I am going to summarize what seems to be the only worthy thought here. A team named N4zi with team members named after historical Nazi party members including Hitler is just not acceptable to us in this game as a Ladle team, period. No new rule needed. In several European countries in which this game is played, such would be illegal. Most any other name, within the limits of "family friendly" is pretty much fair game. Lucifer is fine. I say that as a well known Christian, by the way.
No, the only thing nearly as ridiculous as this team name is the balderdash of debate about it. None is needed. What is there to debate? Even if you are going to forgo the offensive nature of the name, it's illegal in some relevant countries!
It is your opinion that the thread is "balderdash".

What is and isn't acceptable to you or anyone else is what is being discussed. A rule would be needed for ANY such case, regardless if it's about Nazis or not.
Though I can respect you have an opinion that no rule is needed. You reasoning however is based on the very same prejudice and discrimination against Nazis. If you are going to follow the laws of another country, post the law here and suggest it for the rule regarding limitations for team names.

You mention "family friendly", well sorry to break it to you, "N4zi" would classify as family friendly.
A TV show (world famous, known for being family friendly) named "The Simpsons" features episodes that include Nazis, and even "Hitler" (you're left to assume that) killing! One episode even depicts Maggie Simpson (the baby) doing the Nazi salute (Hail Hitler). These would be an offense worthy of a ban (by the arguments shown in this thread)...so why is it considered "family friendly"?
The point is that there is a line between being overly-sensitive and enforcing what's right. It would be like telling a comedian that they weren't allowed to joke about Nazis (even if that was their best bit).
What I'm arguing is the freedom to represent yourself (for anyone) without it having to be considered an offense in the first place. A rule would solve that issue.

You say "Lucifer" is fine like as if you could vouch for all Christian religions. I know for a FACT that SOME Christians would find that VERY offensive. Does that mean I think Lucifer should change his name? NO. I still support the freedom he has to represent himself the way he chooses. IMO, those Christians would be overly-sensitive.

Overall, I would like to see the laws prohibiting the use of Nazi representation (and/or just the word itself, including any variation that could be interpreted as such, like N4zi where the 4 is an A).
People keep saying that this team is acting against some laws, yet I'm unable to find any reference saying that it is illegal to identify yourself as a Nazi. This is the closest I could come up with: Link 1 Link 2.
As you can see from both links, they mostly relate to identifying others as Nazis (which is illegal, yes), and to the overall use of the word "Nazi" (which is perfectly legal).

The "offensive nature of the name" as you call it, is relative to an individual perspective. Bias. Prejudice.
Amaso.
On Lightcycle Grid
Posts: 28
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2015 9:44 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Amaso. »

[quote="Durf"]
@Amaso.: You raise a VERY valid point (assisted by Monkey). If a team name is put up to this much scrutiny, and a forum name "Hitler" was indeed renamed forcibly, then it stands to reason that Lucifer should be forced to rename as well. It can be VERY offensive to many religious people. Think of how many people won't even try to play a corrupted and demonic game? (Moderator associates with the devil; some Christians are told to avoid bad associations by their God.)
I'd like to see what Lucifer has to say about this, as any defense he has for his name is defending a team name like "N4zi" to be able to exist (just as his name exists without problem).
To be clear, I support the freedom to represent yourself how you choose.


(Also @Lucifer, refer to my reponse "@Amaso.". I'd like to see what you have to say regarding what Amaso. and Monkey posted.)

£50 the tyrant, Lucifer, tries to avoid this.
User avatar
takburger
Match Winner
Posts: 600
Joined: Tue Jun 04, 2013 9:34 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by takburger »

Durf wrote: @takburger, you realize you're talking about tronners right? Not actual Nazis?
It's just a team name...People seem to be forgetting that. And even if they were REAL Nazis...what are they doing to this community? Participating in ladle? OH NOES! Seriously though...what crime is being committed?
You are getting so caught up in trying to protect what is right that you lost sight of what's actually happening here. Don't get so worked up over the word "Nazi", this is tron, we're dealing with a team name (as others point out about forum names, there is plenty to get offended over, but why would you when you can have the understanding that you're just playing a game together.)
Playing with Nazis (or fake "N4zi"s / trolls trolling) does NOT mean you support or condone Nazism IRL. You are the only one making that relation, and that is the cause of you feeling offended by the name.
YES it is a game, YES they won't kill anyone in playing the game.

BUT, carrying this game endorse the actions and it is a crime here in Europe called "APOLOGY OF VIOLENCE" and other things. Because you see, IDEAS are MORE POWERFUL than anything in this world.

If I take a baby and raise him saying that Nazi is fine and nice, what do you think will happen ?

Unfortunately we had countless examples this year, in France :
- Rom baby dead born, mayor refused to burry him coz he was Rom
- Black minister, insulted of monkey
- Books written about how muslims should be "deported"
- Boats in Mediterranean sea with immigrants from Syria sinking and fishing boats around not helping them
- Looting of cemeteries with svatzikas (nazi one is different than the original one btw you did a mistake)
- so many other examples...

If you can't see what is wrong, go open sociology, ethical, marketing, communication, buddhism, philosophic books. But now I'm not willing to help you see anymore, I'm out.
Image
User avatar
Z-Man
God & Project Admin
Posts: 11710
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2005 6:01 pm
Location: Cologne
Contact:

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Z-Man »

Information: "Amaso." is indeed old Amoso. And therefore banned for a bit. He also is FluffyBunnyRabit. Tough luck.

Also, I have been very ill since Friday. Tank, Lucifer: any reason why this is not locked? I haven't waded through all the dung yet.
Word
Reverse Adjust Outside Corner Grinder
Posts: 4310
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2009 6:13 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Word »

Ugh, I hope it's nothing serious. Get well soon!
User avatar
Tank Program
Forum & Project Admin, PhD
Posts: 6712
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 7:03 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Tank Program »

Z-Man wrote:Tank, Lucifer: any reason why this is not locked? I haven't waded through all the dung yet.
Relatively constructive discussion has been taking place and it hasn't been going in circles. (I think that point is shortly approaching though at which point I am planning to lock it.)

Get well soon!
Image
notAmaso
Posts: 6
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2015 1:50 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by notAmaso »

Blueberry lollypops.
User avatar
Z-Man
God & Project Admin
Posts: 11710
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2005 6:01 pm
Location: Cologne
Contact:

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Z-Man »

I'll be fine, it was just high and long fever and toilet trouble. Sleep deprivation and the fever had me wondering how many eyes I have at one point in the night, that was new to me. It's mostly over. Right now, I'm basically a couch potato by doctor's orders, getting my electrolytes back in order (munching salty snacks).

Durf: Has the possibility occurred to you that you may be wrong, even very wrong, about some things and that what you perceive as harassment is simply the rightful flak you receive? It's only harassment if it doesn't stop if you stop talking. It's only racism if even after you changed your lifestyle, haircut, moved to a different city, altered your political views, the same group of people still hates you for some thing you cannot change, some thing they somehow still recognize. You cannot be racist against Nazis.

Legal information: Probably fewer things than you think are illegal here in Germany. Public display of the Hitler Greeting or the Swastika, denial of the Holocaust. If any of those would find their way to the wiki, they'd have to be removed. And the original NSDAP is banned as a party. But I don't even think glorification of the NS regime is under penalty.
User avatar
Jonathan
A Brave Victim
Posts: 3391
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 12:50 am
Location: Not really lurking anymore

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Jonathan »

Durf wrote:@Johnathan [more sic]:
Yes, Nazism "technically" "hates" "Jews" (at least before the war it did). But that doesn't mean that Nazis or Nazism = genocide. Nor does it mean that anyone who is Nazi performs such acts (not all Nazis are criminals, not all Nazis kill). What you are feeling is prejudice. Negative emotions based on a preconception your formed from history (rather, the parts that were taught to you) and what you see in TV and movies. The "problem" isn't that they act out the associations (whether or not it's just a joke)...the "problem, is that YOU don't like Nazis based on what YOU think they are. YOU want to disallow a tronner to name THEIR OWN TEAM a name they want because YOU have bad feelings over a word...a single word. I'm not defending Nazism nor am I condoning it. I'm clearing up the difference between complete bias and what is actually harmful to others.
As I said in another thread, if the word gets you so worked up, why aren't you complaining about TV or movies, History books, and this thread itself? This thread alone mentions the word "Nazi" more times that the team name "N4zi" would appear on people's screens over the course of the ladle. Consider why you're allowing it to occur here, but not there. (clue: it's context. You're purposely interpreting a negative context for the team name)
Affirming the consequent much?

Image
Durf wrote:Furthermore, I don't pretend I live in a vacuum where nothing means anything, rather I'm aware that any one thing can have multiple meanings. Far from naivety, it's the realization that one doesn't have to make a complete ass of himself by making assumptions on what means what. Just because I play "Devil's advocate" from time to time, it shouldn't mean I myself should be condemned for the position I'm discussing.
Words have meaning. The extent to which such meaning is expressed can be modulated by context. That's language for you. Language is a fluid thing defined by wide usage. You cannot assert that a language is something it is not, or you will misunderstand and be misunderstood stemming from your own naïveté. It also isn't clear that there's a mere misunderstanding, assuming that's what it is.
Durf wrote:When you say "going full Nazi?", you have no proof that they are Nazi or even trying to associate themselves as REAL Nazis. It could be merely for shock value. Why is that reason to ban it? Really, all desires to ban it are based on the preconceptions you carry around with you.
I'm okay with any kind of radical expression on the condition that the reason it's radical is undermined. One does not simply undermine Nazism, and one does not play games with it.

I'll end this here. You can't say I didn't try.
ˌɑrməˈɡɛˌtrɑn
Amas0
Posts: 4
Joined: Wed Jan 07, 2015 7:30 pm

Re: unfortunately named persons and teams

Post by Amas0 »

I AM A CHRISTIAN AN I DEMAND TO BE HEARD. I AM STRONGLY OFFENDED BY Lucifer's forum name. Lucifer still waiting on new forums name k ty
Last edited by Z-Man on Wed Jan 07, 2015 7:58 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Wait, actually I don't have to edit that to make him soud like a lunatic.
Locked