Ladle 44
Moderator: Light
Re: Ladle 44
Flex is wrong about Team unknown also being incomplete. The revision he linked to was done at 3:55 GMT on the cutoff day. Here is the last revision of the Challenge Board before the brackets were set.
Re: Ladle 44
Oh right, my bad. The bracket template linked in confused me into thinking the brackets were done before the roster update.
Re: Ladle 44
Check the history and edits again. You're basically linking the illegal edit from the final cut-off time. That is Mkay and he edits himself OFF the illegal edit AFTER 18:01 GMT. He basically remove himself from the roster of the illegal edit. He's not even the captain. No other LEGAL edit is done before the cut-off.
Am I still wrong?
No harm done considering he was just removing himself from a team he possibly didn't want to be included on.
[email protected] edits his own team which is a legal edit and is allowed, so not both teams, just one. My bad, on that though.
EDIT: While also looking again. Pr33min3nt ([email protected]) has again edited both teams and made more than 2 changes.
http://wiki.armagetronad.net/index.php? ... ldid=31964
P.S. Psy's made the decision for SP. My questions and statements still stand, but not on representation of Speeders team position, but rather in the actions taken.
Am I still wrong?
No harm done considering he was just removing himself from a team he possibly didn't want to be included on.
[email protected] edits his own team which is a legal edit and is allowed, so not both teams, just one. My bad, on that though.
EDIT: While also looking again. Pr33min3nt ([email protected]) has again edited both teams and made more than 2 changes.
http://wiki.armagetronad.net/index.php? ... ldid=31964
P.S. Psy's made the decision for SP. My questions and statements still stand, but not on representation of Speeders team position, but rather in the actions taken.
Last edited by Flex on Sun Apr 03, 2011 3:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- ElmosWorld
- Match Winner
- Posts: 610
- Joined: Wed Jun 16, 2010 5:38 pm
Re: Ladle 44
Looks like a switch of 2 players to me which is legal.
Slash and Jip for Noob Saibot and Luzifer.
Slash and Jip for Noob Saibot and Luzifer.
Re: Ladle 44
I don't see much of a problem, because while Mkay did illegally edit his team by removing his name, he did put his name back on a few hours later. So he did nothing in total. I wish that he had asked his team leader to do it, but really it is no big deal.Flex wrote:Check the history and edits again. You're basically linking the illegal edit from the final cut-off time. That is Mkay and he edits himself OFF the illegal edit AFTER 18:01 GMT. He basically remove himself from the roster of the illegal edit. He's not even the captain. No other LEGAL edit is done before the cut-off.
Am I still wrong?
No harm done considering he was just removing himself from a team he possibly didn't want to be included on.
[email protected] edits his own team which is a legal edit and is allowed, so not both teams, just one. My bad, on that though.
EDIT: While also looking again. Pr33min3nt ([email protected]) has again edited both teams and made more than 2 changes.
http://wiki.armagetronad.net/index.php? ... ldid=31964
P.S. Psy's made the decision for SP. My questions and statements still stand, but not on representation of Speeders team position, but rather in the actions taken.
Last edited by owned on Sun Apr 03, 2011 4:05 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Ladle 44
If you want to argue that those edits are against the rules (and some of them might be) and that those involved should be punished, go ahead. However, if you want to be an enforcer of the rules you shouldn't be upset that your team lost its seed and was not included in the initial bracket. I don't see any preferential treatment by the organizers, but maybe you do. There are specific rules about what constitutes a team on the Challenge Board, and how a team retains a seed.
Re: Ladle 44
Here is the deal kiddies, I had 2 choices: Follow the rules, leaving SP off the brackets and get crap from them, or break the rules and randomize 2 empty teams and get crap from everyone else. Nice choice eh?
Everyone has something bad to say about how I volunteer my time, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of volunteers stepping up to do "my job" better - especially not from the Speeders clan. I implore you, as I have in the past, to please be more involved in the process. I'll gladly go do something else with my time.
And Flex, you should be proud instead of angry. You helped create these rules. And they work! The same set of rules that prevented SP from playing actually got them back into the game. That's a good system man, because the goal has always been to give everyone a chance to play. There is really no problem here. Everything was solved smoothly before you even showed up.
And it's not like you need a seed anyway, you'll probably win Ladle anyway, haha. GL guys.
Everyone has something bad to say about how I volunteer my time, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of volunteers stepping up to do "my job" better - especially not from the Speeders clan. I implore you, as I have in the past, to please be more involved in the process. I'll gladly go do something else with my time.
And Flex, you should be proud instead of angry. You helped create these rules. And they work! The same set of rules that prevented SP from playing actually got them back into the game. That's a good system man, because the goal has always been to give everyone a chance to play. There is really no problem here. Everything was solved smoothly before you even showed up.
And it's not like you need a seed anyway, you'll probably win Ladle anyway, haha. GL guys.
Re: Ladle 44
The ladle page is currently down. Any explanations?
Re: Ladle 44
does this mean i cant add 1200 because i completely forgot he was on my team even though he always is.
Re: Ladle 44
Thanks, problem solved.
Re: Ladle 44
He can play as a sub. No need to write him in. Just make sure he plays for your team before the semi-finals.teen wrote:does this mean i cant add 1200 because i completely forgot he was on my team even though he always is.
Re: Ladle 44
We found some viagra spam hack thing on the Wiki, probably completely unrelated Have a bracket screenshot while it's down for investigation.